Key stages in Victoria’s criminal court process
- Filing hearing
- After charges are laid, the first hearing (in Magistrates’ Court of Victoria) is the filing hearing. The court sets a timetable, including when the prosecution must serve the “hand-up brief” (evidence) to the accused, and fixes a date for the next step: the committal mention.
- Committal mention
- The committal mention is a preliminary/admin hearing. The court checks whether a full committal hearing is needed; which witnesses (if any) must attend; and sets a committal hearing date.
- Sometimes the accused may plead guilty or not guilty at this stage.
- Committal hearing
- If a committal hearing is scheduled, this is where the court tests whether there is enough evidence for the charges to proceed to trial. Prosecution witnesses may give oral evidence (if permitted), and the defence may cross-examine them.
- If the magistrate finds evidence of sufficient weight, the accused is “committed” for trial in a higher court. If not, the charges may be dismissed.
- Pre-trial / directions hearings (higher court)
- Once committed, the case moves to a higher court (e.g., County Court of Victoria or Supreme Court of Victoria). There may be pre-trial or directions hearings to organise the trial (set dates, finalise disclosure, resolve procedural/legal issues).
- Trial
- At trial, evidence is fully tested before a judge — often with a jury (in serious cases). The prosecution must prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt; verdict follows.
References:
What is bail (in Victoria)
- Bail allows a person charged with a criminal offence to be released from custody while they wait for their court hearing or trial — instead of being remanded (kept in jail).
- The released person must accept certain conditions (or “undertakings”) that the court or police/bail-justice sets.
- Bail is regulated under the Bail Act 1977 (Victoria).
- If bail is refused, the person is remanded in custody — meaning they stay in prison (or youth justice facility) until their case is resolved.
Why bail is important (the purpose)
Under Victorian law, bail serves several key purposes
It respects the principle that a charged person is presumed innocent until proven guilty — giving them freedom until their trial.
It reduces unnecessary use of custody, especially for people charged with less serious offences — helping avoid overcrowding in jails and enabling individuals to maintain their life (job, housing, family) while awaiting trial.
It balances individual rights with public safety — by allowing release under conditions, thereby protecting victims, witnesses, and the community.
Why security / conditions / surety matter
When bail is granted, it’s often subject to conditions or a bail guarantee / surety. These matters because:
- Conditions (like reporting to police, living at a fixed address, not contacting certain people, surrendering passports, curfews) help reduce the risk that the accused will abscond, commit further offences, interfere with witnesses, or obstruct justice.
A bail guarantee or surety (e.g., money or property guarantee, or a guarantor) gives the court a financial or personal guarantee that the accused will appear in court — providing added incentive to comply.
If the accused fails to meet bail conditions (e.g., does not appear in court, re-offends, or interferes with evidence), their bail may be revoked and they may be returned to custody.
How bail decisions are made (Victorian bail law)
- Under the law, bail is granted unless the decision-maker finds there is an “unacceptable risk” in releasing the person. Such risks include: failing to attend court, committing offences while on bail, interfering with witnesses or evidence, or endangering others.
- For more serious offences, additional or stricter bail-tests apply. In those cases, the accused must show why bail should be granted (i.e., that risks can be managed).
- Conditions and sureties are tools used to manage those risks — helping ensure bail works as intended: allowing release while protecting the community and ensuring the accused returns for court.
References:
What is circumstantial evidence in Victoria
- Circumstantial evidence refers to evidence that does not directly prove a fact (like an eyewitness or video would) but instead shows facts or circumstances from which the court may infer the relevant fact.
- In a case relying on circumstantial evidence, the court can convict if — when all pieces are considered together — they satisfy the jury “beyond reasonable doubt.”
How Victorian courts treat circumstantial evidence
- The law in Victoria does not treat circumstantial evidence as inferior by default: a purely circumstantial case is valid and can support a conviction.
- A judge’s directions to a jury in a circumstantial case often explain that the jury may draw a conclusion from a combination of facts, even if none alone proves the offence — emphasising that circumstantial evidence may be as strong as direct evidence.
- That said — because circumstantial evidence depends on inference — the court must ensure that no reasonable hypothesis consistent with innocence remains plausible. If such a hypothesis exists, a conviction may not be safe.
Legal framework in Victoria
- The substantive law of evidence in Victoria is governed by Evidence Act 2008 (Vic). Under the Act, evidence must be relevant to facts in issue to be admitted — and that includes indirect or circumstantial evidence, provided its relevance is demonstrated.
- For jury trials where circumstantial evidence forms a key part of the case, judges may give specific directions about how inferences should be drawn, and warn jurors against speculation or jumping to conclusions.
References:
What is direct evidence (in Victorian / Australian context)
- Direct evidence is evidence that proves a fact directly, without needing inference or deduction.
Common examples of direct evidence include:
- A witness who testifies under oath that they saw the defendant commit the act (e.g. “I saw X stab Y”)
- A video or CCTV recording showing the crime occurring.
- A confession by the accused (i.e. a statement by the accused admitting the crime).
- Under the rules of evidence that govern Victorian courts — namely Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) — evidence must be “relevant” to a fact in issue to be admissible.
- When a witness gives first-hand testimony (what they personally saw / heard / perceived), that qualifies as direct evidence.
How it works in trial & its significance
- Direct evidence gives a straight link between the act and the accused — making it often very powerful, because no inference is needed.
- That said — under Victorian law, direct evidence is not required for a conviction. Cases can be proved with circumstantial evidence alone (or a mix), as long as the total evidence satisfies the standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt.
- Sometimes what starts as direct evidence of one fact may also feed into broader inferences — for example, a witness seeing the accused holding a weapon is direct evidence of possession; that same witness-testimony may support circumstantial argument that the accused used the weapon in a crime.
References:
Beyond reasonable doubt (Victoria)
- Definition: “Beyond reasonable doubt” is the highest standard of proof in criminal law. It means the jury or judge must be firmly convinced of the accused’s guilt before returning a conviction.
- It is not the same as “beyond all possible doubt” — absolute certainty is not required. The focus is on whether, after considering all the evidence, there is any reasonable doubt left about the accused’s guilt.
- Purpose: This standard protects the accused’s rights and ensures that only when the evidence is strong enough to exclude reasonable uncertainty can a conviction occur.
How it works in practice
- The jury considers all evidence, both direct and circumstantial.
- If after reviewing the evidence they have a reasonable doubt — a doubt based on logic or reason — they must acquit.
- If they are sure beyond reasonable doubt that the accused committed the crime, they can convict.
References:
What is burden of proof (Victoria)
- Definition: The burden of proof refers to the duty or responsibility of a party in a legal case to prove a fact or allegation. In criminal law, it is usually the prosecution’s responsibility to prove that the accused committed the offence.
- Who carries it:
- Criminal cases: The prosecution always carries the burden of proof — the accused does not have to prove their innocence.
How it works in practice
- In a criminal trial, the prosecution must present enough evidence to meet the standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt.
- If the prosecution fails to meet this burden, the court must acquit the accused.
- Sometimes the accused may bear a reverse onus in limited circumstances (e.g., certain defences or statutory presumptions), but generally the burden rests with the prosecution.
References:
Who pays for victims of crime in Victoria
- Responsible Body: The Victorian Government pays compensation to victims through VOCAT. The Tribunal assesses applications and decides on financial assistance.
- Source of funds: Payments come from the Victims of Crime Fund, which is funded by fines, penalties, and certain court-ordered payments made by offenders. This is public money, not directly from the offender, though offenders may sometimes be ordered to contribute.
- What can be paid: Compensation can cover things like:
- Medical, dental, and counselling expenses
- Lost income due to the crime
- Funeral expenses (in cases of homicide)
- Other reasonable financial losses directly caused by the crime
How it works
- A victim applies to VOCAT for financial assistance.
- VOCAT assesses the claim and may order payment from the Victims of Crime Fund.
- The offender is not personally paying unless the court specifically orders restitution; otherwise, payments are made by the state fund.
References:
Trial by judge in Victoria
- Summary Offences: Most minor offences, such as traffic offences or minor assaults, are dealt with in the Magistrates’ Court, which only has a judge or magistrate. There is no jury, and the magistrate decides guilt.
- Indictable Offences: More serious offences, like murder, rape, or armed robbery, are usually tried in the County or Supreme Court. Normally, these trials are by judge and jury. However, judge-alone trials are allowed in some circumstances. A defendant may request a judge-alone trial, or in rare cases, the court may order it for efficiency or safety reasons.
- Purpose: Judge-alone trials remove the jury and rely entirely on the judge’s assessment of the evidence. This is usually chosen when the case is legally complex, technical, or for safety or security reasons.
References:
Appealing a conviction and sentence in Victoria
1. Appealing a conviction
- A conviction occurs when a court finds a person guilty of a criminal offence.
- If a person believes the conviction was unjust — for example, because of a legal error, misinterpretation of evidence, or incorrect application of the law — they can appeal the conviction.
- The appeal asks a higher court to review whether the original trial was conducted correctly and whether the verdict should stand.
2. Appealing a sentence
- A sentence is the punishment imposed after a conviction (e.g., imprisonment, fine, community correction order).
- A convicted person can appeal the sentence if they believe it is too harsh, excessive, or legally inappropriate.
- The appeal is considered by a higher court, which can:
- Confirm the sentence
- Reduce or adjust the sentence
- In rare cases, increase the sentence (usually if the prosecution appeals)
3. Process in victoria
- Appeals from the Magistrates’ Court usually go to the County Court.
- Appeals from the County or Supreme Court usually go to the Court of Appeal (Supreme Court of Victoria).
- Appeals must be lodged within a strict timeframe and usually require legal representation.
- Appeals are generally based on questions of law or errors in procedure, not simply disagreement with the outcome.
References:
How much discount do you get if you plead guilty in Victoria
In Victoria, there is no fixed automatic discount for pleading guilty. The amount of reduction in sentence depends on several factors, including the seriousness of the offence, harm caused, the timing of the plea, the offender’s level of remorse, and any prior criminal record.
Generally, the earlier a guilty plea is entered, the greater the potential reduction in sentence. Courts have discretion and use an “instinctive synthesis” approach, balancing all relevant sentencing factors. Empirical data shows that guilty-plea reductions often fall in the 20–30% range, but this is not guaranteed. The court may also indicate what the sentence would have been if the offender had not pleaded guilty, to show transparency about the reduction.
In practice, pleading guilty early and showing full responsibility tends to give the best chance of a meaningful sentence reduction, but the final decision always rests with the judge or magistrate.
References:
Understanding the average wait time for appeals in Victoria
In Victoria, the wait time for appeals varies depending on the type of case and the court involved. Here’s a breakdown to help you understand what to expect.
- Civil appeals – Supreme Court of Victoria (Court of Appeal):
Civil appeals in the Supreme Court typically take 8 to 10 months from the time the appeal is filed until a final decision is made. According to the Supreme Court’s 2023–24 report, the median time for finalisation was around 10 months. - Criminal appeals:
Criminal appeals historically took longer to resolve, but reforms in recent years have helped reduce delays. The exact time can vary depending on the complexity of the case and the court’s scheduling. - Important notes:
It’s important to understand that “wait time” can mean different things. Some may refer to the time until the appeal hearing, while others consider the time until a final decision is delivered. The figures above reflect the total time until the appeal is finalised.
References:
How to access legal aid in Victoria
What is Victoria legal aid (VLA)
- VLA provides free legal information to all Victorians.
- It can also offer free or low-cost legal advice and, in some cases, assign a lawyer if you qualify.
How to contact VLA
- Phone: Call the Legal Help line on 1300 792 387 (Monday to Friday, 8 am–6 pm).
- Online chat: Available through VLA’s website for legal information.
- In person: Offices across Victoria may provide in-person support if your case is accepted.
- Accessibility support: Interpreters and National Relay Service support are available.
When VLA might help you
- Assistance is generally based on a means test considering income, assets, expenses, and dependency.
- If eligible, you may receive a grant of legal assistance, which can include legal advice, document preparation, or court representation.
- Free “duty lawyer” services are available for certain court or tribunal matters.
- If you do not qualify for full assistance, VLA can provide free legal information and referrals.
What to do when contacting VLA
- Clearly describe your legal problem (e.g., criminal, family, tenancy, debt).
- Have relevant documents ready (letters, fines, court papers, payslips, income statements).
- Request a grant of legal assistance if you need financial support to afford a lawyer.
Alternative or additional legal help services
- Community legal centres (CLCs) provide free legal advice or representation depending on the situation.
- Pro bono referral services assist people who cannot pay and are not eligible for legal aid.
- Specialist services may be available for areas like tenancy, discrimination, mental health, or social security issues.
References:
Freedom of information (FOI) requests in Victoria
What is FOI?
Freedom of Information (FOI) is the right to access documents held by Victorian government agencies, departments, and local councils. It allows the public to see information about how decisions are made and how public resources are used.
What you can request
- Government reports, emails, letters, and policies
- Decisions made by agencies affecting you
- Planning, environmental, or council records
- Historical or archived government documents
How to make a request
- Identify the agency holding the information.
- Submit a written request – usually online, by email, or post. Include:
- Your name and contact details
- A clear description of the documents you want
- Pay any fees – some agencies may charge a processing fee, though minor requests can be free.
- Wait for a response – agencies generally respond within 30 days.
Your Rights
- You can appeal if your request is denied, either internally or through the Victorian Information Commissioner.
- Agencies must provide access unless there is a valid exemption (e.g., personal privacy, security, commercial confidentiality).
References: